You have to do more than verify the construction of the bearing wall, you have to find out if your foundation and footing can take the load of an extra floor. Since the vaulted ceiling already rests on these walls you can assume that it's at least designed to support that, but is it designed for an additional floor? Is it a 2x4 wall or 2x6?
But getting back to the lag bolt question, I personally think that it's a bad idea to use them in this case because you have a whole floor with furniture, people and pets resting on the shear strength of lag bolts. Secondly, how do you know how many to use? Too few and you risk collapse from the lag bolts failing, too many and you risk your ledger failing because of the weakened state you put the ledger in where it comes into contact with the stud. Also I would absolutely not leave the sheetrock on the wall and bolt the lag bolt to the studs with that behind it. The sheetrock has absolutely no structural properties whatsoever, leaving 1/2" of the lagbolt "exposed" before it enters the bearing stud - this is a big no no. Now you've entered a bending moment into the lag bolts that wasn't there before. Clear as mud?
But, assuming that you've verified that existing conditions will allow an extra floor, you don't need to tear off the sheetrock down to the floor, just a foot or so below the bottom of the new floor, a good taper can fix that joint such that you never know it was there. You'd have to sheetrock the new ceiling anyway.
One last thing, I do remodels all the time and this is the type of job that I bring a structural engineer in and have a site inspection done, then get a letter stating that site conditions will allow the new project. You just can't go in blindsighted and hope it will hold, peoples lives are at stake - pay the $200 to have a professional look at it.
General Contractor/Home Builder